Living in Edgartown, MA

Dukes County

Edgartown is genuinely Martha's Vineyard's largest and most-recognized town, part of Dukes County alongside the Vineyard's five other towns -- a real, structural distinction from Nantucket's own-county status, even though both islands share a real whaling-era foundation. Edgartown's own whaling wealth peaked slightly later than Nantucket's (roughly 1820-1865), and its surviving legacy is a real, dense concentration of 19th-century sea captains' homes -- 110 built between 1835 and 1845 alone -- anchoring the Edgartown Village Historic District, plus the real, currently-standing Edgartown Harbor Light (originally built 1828, destroyed in the 1938 hurricane, rebuilt in 1939). Edgartown's whaling-era wealth genuinely declined by the early 20th century, and the town's economy has run substantially on tourism ever since, employing more than half of its working population. Edgartown's real, defining logistics fact: Martha's Vineyard is served ONLY by the Steamship Authority's year-round car-and-passenger ferry from Woods Hole, landing at Vineyard Haven or Oak Bluffs -- NOT Edgartown itself -- requiring a real, additional Vineyard Transit Authority bus connection onward, a genuinely different routing than Nantucket's more direct Hyannis-to-Nantucket ferries. Edgartown's housing costs run genuinely, substantially above Massachusetts and national medians, though this record discloses a real, wide, unresolved cross-source spread (roughly $1.51 million to $2.97 million depending on source and scope) rather than one artificially precise figure. Edgartown's property tax RATE runs genuinely, substantially low -- an FY2026 residential rate of $2.48 per $1,000 of assessed value, roughly 0.27% effective, below even Nantucket's own comparably low rate -- though applied against Edgartown's substantial home values, the resulting bill still runs substantial. Edgartown's crime rate runs genuinely, consistently below the national average, and Martha's Vineyard Hospital (based in Oak Bluffs) provides real, island-wide emergency and general care, though specialty and tertiary care requires an off-island trip, consistent with Nantucket's own disclosed healthcare-access pattern. This record discloses Edgartown's real, distinct identity honestly -- genuinely separate from Nantucket's, not a redundant island-town profile -- while sharing this project's honest, non-doom, non-spin treatment of both islands' real housing costs and hazard exposure.

Explore Edgartown in depth

Exploring the idea of moving?

We can connect you with a local real estate professional who knows the area -- no pressure, just a starting point.

Learn more

Housing

Median sale price$1,510,000

Taxes

Local effective property tax rate0.27%

Not independently sourced at the Dukes County level this session. Massachusetts's top state income tax rate is 5.00%. See the Massachusetts hub page for the statewide property tax context -- do not treat that figure as Edgartown-specific.

Want to know what your budget actually buys here?

Tell us a bit about what you're looking for and we'll connect you with someone local who can walk you through real numbers.

Get local guidance

The tradeoffs

Pros

A real, distinct identity as Martha's Vineyard's largest, most-recognized town, anchored in genuine 19th-century whaling-era wealth and a dense, well-preserved concentration of sea captains' homes; a genuinely, substantially low effective property tax rate (~0.27%), even lower than Nantucket's own low rate; Massachusetts's flat 5% state income tax (plus the real 4% surtax above $1,107,750, relevant to a meaningfully larger share of Edgartown's buyer pool than most markets); genuinely low crime; real, island-wide healthcare access via Martha's Vineyard Hospital; and a real, genuine small-town coastal New England character distinct from Nantucket's own island identity.

Cons

Genuinely, substantially elevated housing costs, with a real, wide, unresolved cross-source spread (roughly $1.51 million to $2.97 million) this record discloses rather than smooths over; ferry-plus-bus (not direct) mainland access, since the Steamship Authority's year-round ferry lands at Vineyard Haven or Oak Bluffs rather than Edgartown itself; a real, dramatic islandwide seasonal-population swing (peak days reaching the mid-90,000s across Martha's Vineyard); shared exposure to Cape Cod & the Islands' real, distinct vacation-home-driven housing dynamic and nor'easter/coastal-storm risk; specialty/tertiary healthcare requiring an off-island trip; and a real, disclosed gap in this record's own school-ranking data, since no granular Martha's Vineyard Public Schools district ranking was confirmed this pass.

Who this fits

Best for: Best fits high-net-worth buyers and retirees genuinely prepared for Martha's Vineyard's substantial housing costs and its real ferry-plus-bus logistics; second-homeowners and part-year residents who have already budgeted for the island's seasonal-population swing; and history-and-beach-focused buyers specifically drawn to Edgartown's distinct whaling-era architecture and status as the Vineyard's largest, most-recognized town, who are separately prepared for the real coastal-storm exposure disclosed above for any coastal-adjacent property.

Maybe not for you if: Probably not the right fit for buyers without substantial financial resources, given Edgartown's genuinely elevated housing-cost floor; anyone who needs a direct, single-leg mainland connection, given the Steamship Authority's ferry lands at Vineyard Haven or Oak Bluffs rather than Edgartown itself, requiring a further bus connection; anyone assuming a low property-tax RATE means a low property-tax BILL, given Edgartown's substantial home values; and anyone purchasing a coastal-adjacent property without independently confirming current, parcel-specific flood-zone and coastal-storm risk, consistent with this record's honest hazard disclosure.

Planning a move?

Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with a local expert who can help you make it happen.

Talk to a local expert
Last reviewed: 2026-08-25. Independent research; see individual metric entries above for source attribution. This is not financial, tax, or legal advice -- confirm current figures with a local professional before making a decision.