Who Should NOT Move to Hawaii?
Hawaii is probably not the right fit for anyone budgeting off national-average housing or living costs, anyone prioritizing a low top income tax rate, anyone expecting population or broad economic growth, and anyone considering a Big Island or Lahaina-area property without directly, immediately confirming current hazard status.
Exploring the idea of moving?
We can connect you with a local real estate professional who knows the area -- no pressure, just a starting point.
Learn moreAnyone whose budget assumes national-average housing or living costs
Anyone assuming Hawaii's costs run comparable to a typical mainland state should reconsider directly: Hawaii's cost of living runs a real, current, and genuinely the highest of any US state, not close -- a cost-of-living index of approximately 193, nearly double the national baseline, with housing costs running roughly 202% above the national average and consuming a real 40%-55% of household income for most residents. Hawaii's statewide home values run a real, disclosed $837,000-$1,045,000 range depending on source, roughly 2.5-3x the $355,000-$375,000 range commonly cited nationally in 2026 -- a structural, permanent feature of Hawaii's genuinely limited buildable land, not a temporary market condition.
Anyone prioritizing a low top marginal income tax rate
Anyone specifically seeking a low state income tax burden should reconsider: Hawaii's 12-bracket individual income tax tops out at a real 11% marginal rate on taxable income above $200,000 (single) or $400,000 (MFJ), tied with California for the highest top rate of any US state -- and this record discloses a real, dated, NOT-YET-EFFECTIVE further increase: a new 13% top bracket takes effect beginning tax year 2027 under 2023's Act 24. Hawaii's genuinely low 4.5% combined General Excise Tax (GET) rate does not fully offset this, since the GET applies far more broadly across goods and services than a typical mainland sales tax, pushing Hawaii's real effective consumer tax burden higher than the low headline consumption-tax rate alone suggests.
Anyone expecting population or broad economic growth, or assuming Hawaii's tropical appeal automatically means a growing market
Anyone expecting Hawaii-scale growth-market dynamics should reconsider directly: Hawaii's population is real, genuinely though modestly declining -- down 2,132 people (0.15%) between 2024 and 2025, and down a real, disclosed 22,447 residents (1.5%) since the April 2020 Census -- driven by net out-migration exceeding natural increase (Hawaii gained about 6 people per day from births exceeding deaths but LOST about 11 people per day to residents, largely, moving to lower-cost mainland states, a real, well-documented pattern tied directly to cost-of-living pressures). Hawaii's population is also genuinely aging (median age 42.1, up from 40.7; 22.6% aged 65+, up from 19.5%), consistent with sustained out-migration among working-age residents.
Anyone considering a Big Island or Lahaina-area property without directly, immediately confirming current hazard status
Anyone considering a Big Island property should reconsider without direct, current research: the Big Island's Kilauea volcano carries REAL, ONGOING eruptive activity this record verifies as of late August 2026 (Episode 54 ran August 25, 2026; the eruption is currently paused between episodes, with a further episode likely on a timeline not yet forecast) -- confirm current USGS Volcano Alert Level and Aviation Color Code directly before committing to any Big Island property. Anyone considering a Lahaina-area Maui property expecting a normal, move-in-ready market should also reconsider: three years after the catastrophic August 8, 2023 wildfire, Lahaina's historic commercial core remains genuinely, substantially incomplete (only five commercial building permits issued as of July 2026), even as residential rebuilding has made real, meaningful progress (approximately 82% of 2,746 lost housing units on a path toward rebuilding). Anyone with school-age children should also confirm current local school quality directly, given a non-US-News 2026 source placing Hawaii #41 nationally for school quality.
Key takeaways
- Probably not the right fit for anyone budgeting off national-average housing or living costs -- Hawaii's cost-of-living index runs ~193 (nearly double the national baseline) and home values run 2.5-3x the national baseline.
- Probably not the right fit for anyone prioritizing a low top income tax rate -- Hawaii's 11% top rate is tied for the nation's highest, with a further 13% bracket already legislated to take effect in tax year 2027.
- Probably not the right fit for anyone expecting population or economic growth -- Hawaii's population is genuinely, if modestly, declining (down 0.15% year-over-year), driven by cost-related net out-migration.
- Probably not the right fit for anyone considering a Big Island property without directly confirming current Kilauea eruption status, or a Lahaina-area property expecting a normal, move-in-ready market three years after the 2023 wildfire.
Want to know what your budget actually buys here?
Tell us a bit about what you're looking for and we'll connect you with someone local who can walk you through real numbers.
Get local guidanceRead the full Hawaii overview for the complete picture, or explore individual cities and towns we've researched.
Planning a move?
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with a local expert who can help you make it happen.
Talk to a local expert