Best Places to Live in The Hamptons & the East End
These four East End markets split along genuinely distinct identities that go well beyond generic 'Hamptons' branding: maritime/literary history, formal village character and institutional anchors, and a younger, surf-and-fishing culture -- each fitting a different kind of buyer.
Exploring the idea of moving?
We can connect you with a local real estate professional who knows the area -- no pressure, just a starting point.
Learn moreSag Harbor: Maritime and Literary History
Sag Harbor was genuinely Long Island's largest whaling port, rivaling Salem and New Bedford, MA, and carries a real, nationally significant literary legacy (Melville, Cooper, Heller, Doctorow, Matthiessen, Vonnegut, and Plimpton all lived and wrote there) alongside a historically vital African American community history -- the Sag Harbor Hills, Azurest, and Ninevah Beach neighborhoods, established from 1947 as one of the only places Black families could own beachfront vacation property during the Jim Crow era, the real setting of Colson Whitehead's novel 'Sag Harbor.' It's the pick for buyers drawn to genuine maritime and cultural history over pure resort polish, and it carries the most elevated senior population share among these four (31.2%-34.7% aged 65+).
East Hampton and Southampton: Formal Villages With Institutional Anchors
East Hampton and Southampton both carry a more formal, historically wealthy village character than Sag Harbor or Montauk, but differ in one important way: Southampton is the more institutionally anchored of the two, home directly to Stony Brook Southampton (a Stony Brook University campus) and Stony Brook Southampton Hospital -- the East End's own Level III trauma center -- both located directly in Southampton rather than accessed regionally. East Hampton, by contrast, carries the region's most extreme second-home character: approximately 64.5% of its homes sit vacant at any given time, with only 35.5% occupied year-round, and its own decisively elevated senior demographic (36.3% aged 65+, median age 57) sits at the top of this region's retirement-relevant range.
Montauk: A Younger, Working Surf-and-Fishing Identity
Montauk runs genuinely distinct from the other three: unincorporated, at the very tip of Long Island, home to the historic Montauk Point Lighthouse (1796, the fourth-oldest active lighthouse in the US) and a real, decades-deep surf-and-fishing culture -- a documented 'Surf Fishing Capital of the World' claim and New York State's own largest charter fishing fleet. Its senior population share (roughly 20%, median age 44.7) is genuinely the least elevated of the four Hamptons markets in this dataset, consistent with a younger, seasonal working-town identity rather than a retirement destination -- the clearest pick here for buyers wanting the East End's setting without its most formal, retiree-skewed village character.
Key takeaways
- Sag Harbor offers the region's deepest maritime and literary history, plus a historically significant African American beachfront community heritage, alongside an elevated senior population.
- Southampton is the most institutionally anchored of the four, with a university campus and the East End's own Level III trauma center located directly in the village.
- East Hampton carries the most extreme second-home character (64.5% of homes vacant most of the year) and the highest senior population share of the four.
- Montauk is the clearest pick for a younger buyer wanting East End access without the more formal, retiree-skewed village character of its neighbors -- and it's the region's only unincorporated hamlet.
Want to know what your budget actually buys here?
Tell us a bit about what you're looking for and we'll connect you with someone local who can walk you through real numbers.
Get local guidanceRead the full The Hamptons & the East End overview for the complete picture, including every city and town we've researched in the area.
Planning a move?
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with a local expert who can help you make it happen.
Talk to a local expert