Crime & Safety in New Braunfels
New Braunfels' crime picture is genuinely unsettled across sources in a way worth disclosing plainly rather than smoothing over: NeighborhoodScout describes a resident's combined violent-or-property crime odds at about 1 in 68 and a rate 'considerably higher than the national average,' while separate sources (AreaVibes, a Doorprofit aggregator, and CrimeGrade) describe a rate 44-47% below the national average and assign an A- safety grade. These sources don't just disagree on scale -- they disagree on direction, and both readings are kept here.
Exploring the idea of moving?
We can connect you with a local real estate professional who knows the area -- no pressure, just a starting point.
Learn moreTwo Genuinely Conflicting Readings, Not Just Different Scales
NeighborhoodScout puts a New Braunfels resident's chance of being a victim of either violent or property crime at about 1 in 68, with an overall crime rate of 15 per 1,000 residents described as considerably higher than the national average. In direct tension with that, a Doorprofit aggregator cites New Braunfels' overall crime rate at 18.55 per 1,000 people against a national average of 33.37 per 1,000 -- a rate 44% below average -- with violent crime specifically at 2.18 per 1,000 versus 13.32 nationally, and a separate AreaVibes read describes New Braunfels' rate as 47% below the national average. This is a real, unresolved disagreement in direction, not just magnitude, and is disclosed as such rather than picked down to one number.
CrimeGrade and Safest-Neighborhood Data Lean Favorable
CrimeGrade.org assigns New Braunfels an overall safety grade of A- as of 2026, and identifies River Chase, Oak Run, Rockwall Ranch, Avalon Lakes, and Heavenwood at Hunter's Crossing as the city's safest neighborhoods by its 2026 data. This reading is directionally consistent with the AreaVibes and Doorprofit figures above (below-average risk) rather than the NeighborhoodScout figure, though "safest neighborhoods" data by its nature doesn't settle the citywide-average disagreement.
A Real, Disclosed Recent Trend: Violent Crime Down, Property Crime Up
One source citing recent year-over-year trend data reports total crime in New Braunfels up 15.8%, driven by a 23.8% increase in property crime, even as violent crime specifically fell 24.5% over the same period. This is a genuinely mixed, two-directional trend worth stating plainly rather than characterizing as simply "crime is rising" or "crime is falling" -- the category mix matters, and property crime's rise is consistent with a fast-growing city adding population and, likely, opportunistic targets faster than some categories of enforcement or prevention can keep pace.
What This Disagreement Likely Reflects
A precise, independently confirmed explanation for why NeighborhoodScout's reading diverges so sharply from AreaVibes, Doorprofit, and CrimeGrade was not found this session -- these platforms are known to use different underlying data years, different geographic boundaries (city limits vs. a broader ZIP-code or metro area), and different weighting methodologies, any of which could explain a gap this size, but none of the sources reviewed explained their own methodology clearly enough to resolve it here. Anyone weighing crime risk seriously should pull current, address-specific data (or a specific-neighborhood NeighborhoodScout or CrimeGrade report) rather than relying on a single citywide characterization from any one source.
Key takeaways
- Sources genuinely disagree on direction, not just scale: NeighborhoodScout cites a rate 'considerably higher than the national average' (1-in-68 combined violent/property odds), while AreaVibes, Doorprofit, and CrimeGrade all describe a rate well below the national average (an A- safety grade, 44-47% below national depending on source).
- CrimeGrade names River Chase, Oak Run, Rockwall Ranch, Avalon Lakes, and Heavenwood at Hunter's Crossing as the city's safest neighborhoods for 2026.
- One source shows a genuinely mixed recent trend: total crime up 15.8% year-over-year, driven by a 23.8% rise in property crime, even as violent crime fell 24.5% over the same period.
- No source reviewed this session explained the methodology gap behind the conflicting citywide readings -- likely different data years, geographic boundaries, or weighting, but not independently confirmed.
- Given this unusually unsettled picture, pull current, address- or neighborhood-specific crime data directly rather than relying on any single citywide figure in this section.
Want to know what your budget actually buys here?
Tell us a bit about what you're looking for and we'll connect you with someone local who can walk you through real numbers.
Get local guidanceRead the full New Braunfels overview for the complete picture -- housing, taxes, climate, and who this place genuinely fits.
Planning a move?
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with a local expert who can help you make it happen.
Talk to a local expert