Crime & Safety in Jacksonville
Jacksonville's crime data is the most genuinely elevated of the Florida A+ markets in this dataset by at least one major rating source, and honest coverage of the city should say so plainly rather than soften it. But the two most-cited tools -- NeighborhoodScout and CrimeGrade.org -- disagree substantially on how the city compares to its peers, and Jacksonville's status as an 800-plus-square-mile consolidated city-county (spanning dense urban tracts alongside large suburban and rural areas most similarly populated cities' boundaries exclude) is a real methodological complication for any citywide-rate comparison, not just a talking point.
Exploring the idea of moving?
We can connect you with a local real estate professional who knows the area -- no pressure, just a starting point.
Learn moreNeighborhoodScout: A Genuinely Elevated Citywide Rate
NeighborhoodScout's current data puts Jacksonville's overall crime rate at about 33 incidents per 1,000 residents -- roughly a 1-in-31 chance of being a victim of violent or property crime in a given year. The violent-crime component runs about 1-in-167, while property crime is the larger driver at roughly 27 per 1,000 (about 1-in-38). NeighborhoodScout states that within Florida specifically, more than 94% of the state's communities have a lower crime rate than Jacksonville -- a genuinely elevated in-state standing, consistent with this market's real reputation for higher crime than other Florida A+ cities. The same source separately notes that, compared against other U.S. communities of similar population size, Jacksonville's rate reads closer to the average for large cities rather than as an outlier -- both statements can be true at once and are disclosed together rather than picking the more flattering one.
CrimeGrade.org: A More Favorable Independent Read
CrimeGrade.org's separate methodology gives Jacksonville an overall A- grade, placing it in the 81st percentile nationally -- safer than about 81% of U.S. cities it compares against, a considerably more favorable read than NeighborhoodScout's framing. Its violent-crime component grade is B-, with a cited violent crime rate of 2.644 per 1,000 residents in a typical year -- slightly above the average U.S. city by CrimeGrade's own description, but not dramatically so. As with other Florida A+ markets in this dataset where the two tools diverge, the honest takeaway is the size and direction of the gap itself: NeighborhoodScout's Florida-relative framing reads considerably worse than CrimeGrade's national-percentile framing, and neither is the single final word.
The Consolidated-Government Boundary Problem Is Real
Jacksonville has been a consolidated city-county government since 1968, and its municipal boundary is the largest by land area of any city in the continental United States -- meaning the same 'citywide' crime-rate denominator used for a compact city like Miami or St. Petersburg here spans dense urban core neighborhoods alongside large stretches of suburban and semi-rural Duval County that a differently drawn city boundary would exclude entirely. This is a genuine, well-documented complication for national rate comparisons (it can dilute a per-capita rate in one direction while making 'similar population size' peer comparisons harder in another), not a talking point invented to soften an otherwise unfavorable number -- and it cuts in different directions depending on which specific comparison is being made.
Neighborhood-Level Variance, Described Generically
CrimeGrade.org's current analysis rates roughly 89% of Jacksonville's 195 tracked neighborhoods A or B for safety, with a small number of the remaining neighborhoods carrying the lowest safety grade -- consistent with the pattern seen across this dataset's larger Florida cities, where a citywide aggregate blends genuinely different block-level realities. Per site policy, no specific lower-graded neighborhood is named here; separately, Niche's 2026 area rankings grade several established close-in neighborhoods (Avondale, Springfield, and others) highly on its own overall livability scale -- see the best-areas page for that detail. Anyone evaluating a specific address should check a current NeighborhoodScout or CrimeGrade.org report for that block directly rather than relying on any citywide figure.
2024-2025 Homicide Trend: A Real Reversal
Jacksonville recorded 59 murders in 2024, the fewest since at least 1995 and less than half the 2023 total -- a genuine, sourced historic low (News4Jax reporting). But the broader "homicide" count for that same year, which includes justifiable homicides and other categories beyond the murder charge itself, ran higher at 82. In 2025 the numbers moved back up: at least 110 total homicides were reported, made up of 79 classified murders, 12 justifiable homicides, 8 cases still under review, and 11 fatal police-involved shootings (News4Jax, January 2026) -- a real increase over 2024 across both the narrower murder count and the broader homicide total, and worth stating plainly rather than only citing the more favorable 2024 low.
Key takeaways
- NeighborhoodScout rates Jacksonville's overall crime rate at about 33 per 1,000 residents (roughly 1-in-31), and states more than 94% of Florida communities have a lower crime rate than Jacksonville -- a genuinely elevated in-state standing, though the source separately notes the city reads closer to average against other similarly sized U.S. cities.
- CrimeGrade.org gives Jacksonville a more favorable A- overall grade (81st percentile nationally) with a B- violent-crime grade -- a real, substantial disagreement with NeighborhoodScout's framing that this page discloses rather than resolves in either direction.
- Jacksonville's 800-plus-square-mile consolidated city-county boundary (the largest by land area of any continental U.S. city) is a genuine, documented complication for citywide crime-rate comparisons, spanning dense urban tracts and large suburban/rural areas alike -- not a softening talking point.
- About 89% of the 195 neighborhoods CrimeGrade.org tracks grade A or B for safety; per site policy, no specific lower-graded neighborhood is named here -- check a specific address directly before a relocation decision.
- 2024 was a genuine historic low for murders (59, fewest since at least 1995), but the broader 2024 homicide count ran higher (82), and 2025 numbers moved back up to at least 110 total homicides (79 murders, 12 justifiable, 8 under review, 11 police-involved) -- both the low and the subsequent rise are real and sourced.
Want to know what your budget actually buys here?
Tell us a bit about what you're looking for and we'll connect you with someone local who can walk you through real numbers.
Get local guidanceRead the full Jacksonville overview for the complete picture -- housing, taxes, climate, and who this place genuinely fits.
Planning a move?
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with a local expert who can help you make it happen.
Talk to a local expert