Crime & Safety in Scottsdale
Scottsdale's crime data is genuinely, broadly reassuring but carries real, disclosed tension on magnitude and on one specific category: the base Scottsdale record's WalletHub-derived reporting ranks the city 2nd-safest in Arizona and 39th nationally of 182 cities, and a separate 2026 aggregator cites an overall crime rate 45% below the national average with an A- safety grade -- but a third, FBI Uniform Crime Report-based source ranks Scottsdale a much more middling 44th of 65 Arizona cities, and the same reassuring source that cites low violent crime also discloses a property crime rate running slightly above the national average.
Exploring the idea of moving?
We can connect you with a local real estate professional who knows the area -- no pressure, just a starting point.
Learn moreThe Reassuring Read: Well Below National Averages, A- Grade
One 2026 aggregator cites Scottsdale's overall crime rate as 45% below the national average, with an A- crime safety grade and lower crime than 84% of other major US cities. Violent crime specifically is cited at 1.9 per relevant unit versus 13.32 nationally, putting the odds of becoming a violent-crime victim at roughly 1 in 463. This is consistent with the base Scottsdale record's separately sourced WalletHub-derived ranking -- 2nd-safest city in Arizona and 39th nationally out of 182 municipalities surveyed, behind only Gilbert.
A Real, Disclosed Category Exception: Property Crime
The same 2026 source that cites Scottsdale's strong overall and violent-crime standing also discloses a genuine exception: Scottsdale's property crime rate runs slightly above the national average (23.15 vs. 20.05 nationally). This is a real, specific data point worth flagging on its own rather than letting the strong overall/violent-crime numbers imply uniformly below-average crime across every category -- a pattern of category-specific nuance consistent with how this project's build treats crime data elsewhere.
A Separate, More Middling FBI-Based Read
A separate 2026 source (cityrating.com), describing its methodology as based on the FBI's 2024 Uniform Crime Report, ranked Scottsdale a considerably more middling 44th safest of 65 Arizona cities it surveyed, and 7,278th of 9,896 U.S. cities nationally. This is a real, disclosed tension against the WalletHub-derived and A--grade readings above -- not a small rounding difference, but a genuinely different relative-ranking picture from a differently sourced dataset. This file does not attempt to reconcile the two; both are kept, consistent with this project's sourcing discipline.
Neighborhood-Level Data Is Consistently Strong
At the neighborhood level, sourcing is more consistently reassuring: one 2026 crime-mapping source (CrimeGrade.org) reported that all 26 Scottsdale neighborhoods it analyzed earned a Grade A or higher, with McDowell Mountain Ranch and East Shea specifically cited among the safest. Separately, a 2025 neighborhood-safety analysis identified DC Ranch, Silverleaf, Troon North, Ancala, Grayhawk, and McDowell Mountain Ranch -- all gated North Scottsdale communities -- as the city's safest specific neighborhoods. See the best-areas topic page for more on these communities.
What This Means in Practice
Taken together, the weight of sourcing this session leans toward Scottsdale being a genuinely safer-than-average American city, particularly for violent crime and at the neighborhood level in North Scottsdale's gated communities -- but the FBI-UCR-based relative Arizona ranking (44th of 65) and the above-national property crime rate are real, disclosed exceptions that shouldn't be smoothed away. Anyone weighing safety heavily in a relocation decision should pull current, address-specific crime data directly rather than relying on any single citywide superlative.
Key takeaways
- Scottsdale's crime picture is broadly reassuring but genuinely mixed across sources: WalletHub-derived reporting ranks it 2nd-safest in Arizona/39th nationally of 182, and a separate source cites 45% below-national overall crime with an A- grade -- but an FBI-UCR-based aggregator ranked it a more middling 44th of 65 Arizona cities.
- A real, disclosed category exception: even the most reassuring 2026 source cites Scottsdale's property crime rate running slightly above the national average (23.15 vs. 20.05), despite strong violent-crime numbers (1.9 vs. 13.32 nationally).
- Neighborhood-level data is more consistently strong: all 26 neighborhoods analyzed by one crime-mapping source earned Grade A or higher, with McDowell Mountain Ranch, East Shea, DC Ranch, Silverleaf, Troon North, Ancala, and Grayhawk specifically cited among the safest.
- The genuine tension between the WalletHub-derived ranking and the FBI-UCR-based ranking is disclosed rather than resolved -- pull current, address-specific crime data directly for any decision that weighs safety heavily.
Want to know what your budget actually buys here?
Tell us a bit about what you're looking for and we'll connect you with someone local who can walk you through real numbers.
Get local guidanceRead the full Scottsdale overview for the complete picture -- housing, taxes, climate, and who this place genuinely fits.
Planning a move?
Tell us what you're looking for and we'll connect you with a local expert who can help you make it happen.
Talk to a local expert